What's Going on in the Markets March 16, 2025

All the major indexes, including the Dow Jones Industrial Average (30 stocks), S&P 500, Nasdaq, Russell 2000, and even the Wilshire 5000, closed at new 6-month lows on Thursday before a robust bounce on Friday.
Although at its worst moment on Thursday, the S&P 500 index was down almost 10.5% from its recent 52-week high, it managed a decent bounce on Friday but still closed down 8.3% from that peak. Year to date, the index is down 4.1%.
For the week, the S&P 500 lost 5.3%, the NASDAQ dropped 5.8%, and the small caps continued their persistent weakness, falling 5.5%.
Market leadership, especially among technology stocks, showed further deterioration this week, and bearish distribution (institutional selling) continued accelerating. By the end of the week, investor sentiment bordered on extreme fear, one element in the making of a robust market rally.
Though there’s not much to be happy about as an investor, keeping the current pullback in perspective is essential. The S&P 500 index is trading back where it was in mid-September 2024, a mere six months ago. The S&P 500 is still 60% higher than the low made at the start of the current bull market (uptrend) in mid-October 2022.
IT’S THE ECONOMY
Not helping things last Tuesday, the Small Business Optimism Index from the National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB) fell to 100.7 for February (from 102.8 in January and 105.1 in December). The Uncertainty Index rose to its second highest level in the series history—just below the reading reached in October last year.
Uncertainty on Main Street has led to fewer small business owners viewing this as a good time to expand or expecting better business conditions. Enthusiasm over the Trump administration's expected pro-business policies has faded quite a bit.
More favorably, the Bureau of Labor Statistics's Consumer Price Index (CPI) and Producer Price Index (PPI) came in slightly cooler than expected for February, reflecting inflation easing. However, underlying data in both inflation measures indicate that the Federal Reserve’s preferred inflation measure, the Core Personal Consumption Expenditures (or PCE, which comes out at the end of the month), will likely continue to be stubbornly elevated.
Consumer Sentiment drives consumer spending and buoys corporate earnings. Confident consumers are essential to a strong economy, or at least one that can avoid a recession.
Friday’s Overall Consumer Sentiment Index report from the University of Michigan fell dramatically (down 6.8 points to 57.9) for the third consecutive month on concerns ranging from personal finances and the stock market to inflation and labor markets. The Current Conditions Index slid to 63.5, and most concerningly, the Future Expectations Index tumbled 9.8 pts to 54.2, its lowest level since July 2022. Year-ahead inflation expectations spiked to 4.9%, the highest since November 2022.
All three sentiment indexes are now at historically low levels rarely seen outside of recessions. The rapid decline in Consumer Sentiment reflects increased uncertainty about individuals’ perceptions of their financial situation. Uncertainty regarding the future can quickly materialize into a slowdown if consumers cut back on spending or delay big purchases.
This sentiment report marks the most significant two-month increase in inflation expectations since 1980. Consumer attitudes have rapidly changed since the end of last year, and this report headlines the collapse of speculation and exuberance that drove the stock market last year.
IS EVERYTHING BAD OUT THERE?
By most measures, the current pullback has been somewhat orderly, with few signs of investor panic or institutional wholesale dumping of stocks. Some would prefer to see signs of investor panic and some kind of “whoosh” to the downside to signal that a bottom might be in. Instead, what’s happened is a slow “drip” lower akin to water torture that persists for an unknown duration.
As optimistic and pessimistic investors pray for a sustainable bounce, they tend to have opposite objectives. The optimist wants the market to go up to validate their “buy the dip” mentality and produce profits as rewards for their bravery. The pessimistic investors recall past severe market cycles and feel trapped in the market. They will use any bounce or rally to sell stocks and perhaps declare, “Never again!”
These opposing forces are at play on any market day. Still, when the markets decline persistently, as we’ve seen since February 20, the battle between optimists and pessimists can bring about strong emotions and perhaps opposite actions or reactions to the fear, uncertainty, and doubt surrounding a weak market.
So how has this resolved itself in similar scenarios in the past?
A COUPLE OF QUANT STUDIES
We can look to quantitative (quant) studies to help answer the foregoing question.
Analyzing past market historical statistics, often called quantitative analysis, can lead one to believe the market is predictable by studying past patterns. Nothing, and I mean nothing, has definitive predictive power, but humans tend to repeat behaviors repeatedly, making some of these quantitative measures somewhat valuable for review and consideration. They are mere data points in a collection that make up the bulk of market-generated information.
Here are summaries of a couple of quantitative studies from Carson Investment Research:
Quant Study 1: Since World War II, the S&P 500 index has experienced 48 market pullbacks of 10% or more (a 10% pullback is called a “correction” by many). If you subscribe to the notion that a 20% pullback constitutes a definitive bear (downtrending) market, then 12 of those 48 pullbacks (25%) went on to pull back 20% or more. That means that 75% of the time, a 10% pullback did not lead to a bear market.
Quant Study 2: In addition, if we are heading for a 20% pullback, this would be the third 20% pullback in less than five years, something that has never happened since 1950 (which doesn’t mean it can’t happen). Going back to 1950, the last time we had three bear markets this close to each other was between 1966 and 1973, a period spanning 6.9 years. So, another bear market in 2025 would be pretty rare.
So, while most 10% corrections don't evolve into bear markets, the hot money traders' continued complacency and quick-bounce expectations can often precede more significant downturns. Buying the dip, which has worked for years, works until it doesn’t.
GREEN SHOOTS OR BROWNOUTS?
Friday’s bounce notwithstanding, the current price action favors more potential downside unless the market immediately follows through on Friday’s rally to the upside. The market is now significantly oversold, which is historically associated with strong bounces or significant trend changes (from downside to upside). In addition, March corrections frequently stage oversold bounces into recoveries into the end of the calendar quarter.
On another positive note, the next few weeks are seasonably favorable for a continued bounce or rally. This means that historically, this time of the year has been favorable for the markets. If Friday was the spark for a bounce, it could entice more participants to join so they don’t miss the bounce. After all, a rout we’ve seen over the past four weeks deserves more than a one-day wonder rally like we saw on Friday. Indeed, we’ve seen strong reactions to past selloffs comparable to this one. But as they say, “past results don’t guarantee future performance.”
WHAT NOW?
If you’ve been anxious or nervous about market action over the past few weeks, you likely have too much exposure to the stock market. Therefore, it’s prudent to talk to your financial advisor about reducing your overall risk to the “sleeping point.”
If you are the chief investment advisor of your portfolio, take advantage of any rally or bounce to reduce your exposure to better suit your overall risk tolerance. (1)
I won’t repeat everything I said in last week’s What’s Going on in the Markets March 9, 2025. But it bears repeating that we anticipate having a correction of 10% or more at least 1.1 times per year, so this lousy action is normal and shall eventually pass.
A 10% correction turns into a 15% correction about every 40 months (0.3 times yearly). So sure, it could get worse before it gets better, but I’m still not seeing wholesale evidence of a full-on recession or bear market headed our way. We don’t yet have enough proof of that.
If this turns out to be a garden variety correction, and I think it is, taking advantage of the opportunity will pay off for those who have a long-term investing time horizon and are brave enough to step up and buy (it’s never easy to do so, but we did some light buying for our clients last week.) (1)
One of my favorite financial advisors, Keith Fitz-Gerald, often says, “History shows very clearly that missing opportunity is more expensive than trying to avoid risks you can’t control.”
I agree wholeheartedly. Focus on what you can control, and don’t miss the opportunities.
(1) Disclaimer: Nothing in this article recommends that you buy or sell any security. Please consult with your financial advisor before taking any action.
Sam H. Fawaz is the President of YDream Financial Services, Inc., a fee-only investment advisory and financial planning firm serving the entire United States. If you would like to review your current investment portfolio or discuss any other tax or financial planning matters, please don’t hesitate to contact us or visit our website at http://www.ydfs.com. We are a fiduciary financial planning firm that always puts your interests first, with no products to sell. If you are not a client, an initial consultation is complimentary, and there is never any pressure or hidden sales pitch. We start with a specific assessment of your personal situation. There is no rush and no cookie-cutter approach. Each client and their financial plan and investment objectives are different.
Sources: InvesTech Research and The Kirk Report